Zooomr

You have successfully subscribed to this thread!

Topic: Critique

wrote Posted 4 years, 8 months ago
I got this idea from a poetry board. You need to provide feedback as to how the photo can be improved up on. Here is the photo I clicked.

bear_up_close

I think adjusting the levels might bring up on a degree of improvement. What are your suggestions?
wrote Posted on Sept. 5, 2007 (permalink)
Wow, just the fact you got this close to take the pic is good enough for me!
wrote Posted on Sept. 28, 2007 (permalink)
no, what is Most impressive is that HE posted it, not his next of kin,[-(. I see nothing wrong with that shot as is!
wrote Posted on Sept. 28, 2007 (permalink)
Let's be good Zooomrites and expand this thread. Levels might help a bit, but there's nothing seriously wrong with this photo. How many comments before someone else can post a photo to critique?
wrote Posted on Sept. 28, 2007 (permalink)
Maybe a different cropping to imply motion or create a tension? (Where is the bear coming from/going) Maybe make the butt of the bear about the top left corner of the picture?
A post here was deleted on Sept. 28, 2007
wrote Posted on Sept. 28, 2007 (permalink)
I'd crop vertically with less space below the bear and work with the contrast a little to make the bear stand out more.

Yeah, we could continue with it and have more photos, but I'm not too sure how it'd work. Maybe a new group where everyone starts a thread for each photo?
wrote Posted on Sept. 28, 2007 (permalink)
I think the biggest issue is the lack of shadow detail. I've had a go at improving it - what do you think?


Bear_adjust


My method is described in my comment on this image:

http://www.zooomr.com/photos/39586@Z01/2423719/
wrote Posted on Sept. 30, 2007 (permalink)
crop out the geese on the other bank?
duck goose
wrote Posted on Sept. 30, 2007 (permalink)
Yeah I think that's a good idea, it draws my attention away from the main focus and seems distracting.
wrote Posted on Sept. 30, 2007 (permalink)
i kinda thought so too.
wrote Posted on Oct. 4, 2007 (permalink)
have to bump someone is looking for this thread!
wrote Posted on Oct. 4, 2007 (permalink)
Besides cropping out the other geese, I think the photo is a little too bright. Curves would help.
wrote Posted on Oct. 5, 2007 (permalink)
ty fu
wrote Posted on Oct. 7, 2007 (permalink)
7

Took a bunch of shots around this abandoned warehouse and thought they should have been better, but I'm not sure what/why they aren't. Any suggestions would be great.
wrote Posted on Oct. 7, 2007 (permalink)
I think if you would have zoomed in or gotten closer you could have taken a photo of just the valves. Then the effect of the repetition of the valves would be much stronger.
wrote Posted on Oct. 7, 2007 (permalink)
Yeah, think I am going to go back tomorrow and setup with my tripod. I had my f set to 22 but still don't have as much DoF as I thought. probably try 100ISO and get a longer exposure.
wrote Posted on Oct. 7, 2007 (permalink)
I would crop out the fence and leave the yellow pipes, I would work with Levels by pushing down the Shadows slider to the right slightly and your Highlights slider to the left slightly
this adds a bit more contrast and sharpens the photo up a bit

I would then go into selective color and adjust it to get the perfect yellow that you want hope this helps

P.S. I would also add a vignette before the Levels adjustment, then when you go into levels you can adjust how dark the vignette is!
wrote Posted on Oct. 7, 2007 (permalink)
I'm not too familiar with the technical aspects of editing, but regarding the subject matter I would focus of the weather-worn pipes. A wider shot like this dulls the effect, especially when the rest of the scene looks relatively well maintained which I feel, spoils the effect.
wrote Posted on Oct. 7, 2007 (permalink)
Hi!
nice thread here! :)
I'm not an expert, but I think it could be a bit darker. I imagine it would be a bit more moody!
The buildings in the background are a bit distracting too. could you take it from another angle? (the pipes look cool, but the background makes it a bit less special to me)
Or how about a night shot? (where you see no background and just a little light on the pipes) :)
wrote Posted on Oct. 7, 2007 (permalink)
Baby Bear

I know this photo could use improving, just thought maybe I would get some input before I tried anything. See what would make it better for you guys.
wrote Posted on Oct. 8, 2007 (permalink)
I like this shot, the bear's nice and soft compared to the sharper lines of the grass. Would have been nice to see the interaction with the other bear though.
wrote Posted on Oct. 8, 2007 (permalink)
i agree w dare i see (barely) two bears, put what they are doing is hard to tell. you could have afforded to drop out more of the tree if the bears were more interesting.
wrote Posted on Oct. 8, 2007 (permalink)
There were more bear shots I took, hard to get shots of the other baby bears because the big mama grizzly was in the way
A post here was deleted on Oct. 10, 2007
wrote Posted on Oct. 9, 2007 (permalink)
telephoto zoom!! ltms
wrote Posted on Oct. 9, 2007 (permalink)
ltms?
wrote Posted on Oct. 10, 2007 (permalink)
laugh to my self, so sorry.
wrote Posted on Oct. 12, 2007 (permalink)
oh, bump come on guys
wrote Posted on Oct. 14, 2007 (permalink)
ok bump
wrote Posted on Oct. 16, 2007 (permalink)
you spin me round

I like this shot, but I think there is more I could have done.
wrote Posted on Oct. 16, 2007 (permalink)
About the bear image. Is it the lighting or the time of year, but it seems really yellow and washed out. Maybe working with the level in photoshop could help. I had good luck using the techniques in this article http://tinyurl.com/2oj3bm . Hope this isn't too elementary for you, I know I am just learning some of these techniques.
wrote Posted on Oct. 16, 2007 (permalink)
I like this shot, but I think there is more I could have done.

Cutting down the tree?

SCNR, wasn't meant to be derogative, but from what I understand your intention, or at least expectation was, the tree is the spoiling factor. Altering one's expectation about making spectacular photos would be a viable option too.
wrote Posted on Oct. 16, 2007 (permalink)
I think the windmill would look really cool in b&w, particularly if you use channel mixer in Photoshop to make the sky pitch black. It would make the windmill stand out more.
wrote Posted on Oct. 17, 2007 (permalink)
Actually there is something I can learn from your comment. Next time I am out I will think more about checking the subject from all different angles. If I had taken the photo from a different angle I might have been able to avoid the tree.
wrote Posted on Oct. 17, 2007 (permalink)
however now that you have it...
i might use paint (gasp)and edit those elements out, but thats a lot of work!
wrote Posted on Oct. 17, 2007 (permalink)
I only wish I knew how to do that.
wrote Posted on Oct. 17, 2007 (permalink)
Go to Image -> Adjustments -> Channel Mixer. Check the Monochrome box and change the red, green and blue sliders to your heart's content. That's it!
wrote Posted on Oct. 17, 2007 (permalink)
you spin me round in black
wrote Posted on Oct. 17, 2007 (permalink)
Very nice! Although the tree is still a distraction.
wrote Posted on Oct. 17, 2007 (permalink)
It's much nicer now, good job.
wrote Posted on Oct. 17, 2007 (permalink)
Why not cut the tree out in photoshop and put another sky as background? I think there is enough contrast in the windmill (compared to the background) that photoshop can help you with its tools :)
wrote Posted on Oct. 21, 2007 (permalink)
crop?
bed
wrote Posted on Oct. 21, 2007 (permalink)


Yeah I think, or possible find some way to lessen the effect of the background, since it doesn't really contribute to the shot.
wrote Posted on Oct. 21, 2007 (permalink)
Yes, I think like darel. perhaps you could try to darken the background with the dodge/burn tool! And crop off some of the rigt of the image, so the cat is not in the middle, but 2/3 to the right.
wrote Posted on Oct. 21, 2007 (permalink)
oh, and for everybody here: if you want let someone to edit you picture, it would be helpful to post the link to the original (or at least large) version of the picture!
wrote Posted on Oct. 22, 2007 (permalink)
thank you! d/b tool would help if i had more than Just paint-it came with the computer!
wrote Posted on Oct. 22, 2007 (permalink)
thank you! d/b tool would help if i had more than Just paint-it came with the computer!


Didn't come your cam with an image processing software?

If not you might want to download Gimp for free.
A post here was deleted on Oct. 22, 2007
A post here was deleted on Oct. 22, 2007
wrote Posted on Oct. 22, 2007 (permalink)
yes camera came with arc soft,it can do some tricks but...


Want to post a reply?

Please Sign-In OR Sign-Up
< Previous 1 2
( 79 Posts )
Quantcast